The Democratic Legitimacy of Health Care Reform


In light of the Massachusetts Senate race and polls showing popular opposition to comprehensive health care reform, opponents of reform will try to paint efforts to continue the fight as going against the peoples’ wishes. This was happening before the Massachusetts election was even decided. Weekly Standard editor and noted fan of needless death in both hospitals and battlefields William Kristol wrote Monday, “I very much doubt, if Scott Brown wins in Massachusetts, that Nancy Pelosi will be able to persuade 217 other House Democrats to jam Obamacare down the throats of the American people.”

These arguments would make sense if the federal government made decisions based on polls it conducted of the populace, or by referendums in randomly selected states. But it doesn’t. Voters register their opinions through elections, and that is the only form of expression that’s at all relevant. And a look at the numbers there show a country that voted overwhelmingly for representation that would reform health care.

If you add up the populations of all the states where at least one Senator voted for the health care reform bill, the total is about 229 million, or 74.5 percent of the country. This is slightly misleading, though, as it does not account for states where one Senator did not vote for the bill and the other did. So I calculated the figure again, only dividing by two the population of states where this split occurred. The total is 192 million, or 62.767 percent of the country.

Let’s be clear. The vast majority of the country voted to elect representatives who support health care reform. It is the obligation of the Congress to fulfill that mandate and pass comprehensive health care reform. That the undemocratic nature of the Senate and the filibuster makes this difficult is unfortunate, but not an insurmountable barrier.

1 thought on “The Democratic Legitimacy of Health Care Reform

  1. Everything Obama does is destroying America and the capitalist ideals it was built on. Everything he says against the morals and vaulues of America. This “Obamacare” is nothing short of a guise to get the government more into our lives and for them to tax us to death. This will be the start to a long and dangerous road. The road of socialized Medicine. Doctors need to be paid the huge salaries. They earned it. Destroying that and diminishing the quality of care by using “Government regulations” will only cause the issue to get worse. Look at how government handles things. Look at the TARP program and the Big Dig. Both horrible failures and waste of tax dollars. The only solution to this health care issue is TORT reform and less government red tape. Why do Americans need the government to regulate how healthy we are? Why do we want Obama to penalize people for being successful with more taxes? Obama will be the down fall of America. He will turn us into a European welfare state. Do you know what happens when the government pays everyone to not work? The economy stalls and unemployment skyrockets. European Countries that Liberals drool over are in worse shape than us. The recession hit them harder than us. Socialism and over taxing is to blame. Do we really want to model that terrible system? I sure don’t. You should look at what your liberals are really doing. Do you really want to pay for all these programs that will never do anything for you?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s