Ed Whelan is Absolutely Despicable

This is just a painful thing to watch. So publius of Obsidian Wings – who’s an outstanding blogger you should all be reading – has been outed by Ed Whelan at The Corner for a single post he wrote criticizing Whelan’s simplistic and laughable views about Sonia Sotomayor. publius responded to an initial accusatory email from Whelan by politely explaining that he had private, family, and professional reasons for using a pseudonym. Whelan responded by calling publius a “coward and idiot”.

There is nothing defensible about this. Absolutely nothing. The post in which Whelan outs publius doesn’t even contain a response to his arguments, just ad hominem attacks and claims that publius – who’s a law professor – has “a dismal understanding of the legal matters he opined on” (which, judging from Whelan’s hilarious misunderstanding of the role of policy in the legal system, seems like all too much projection). And his claim that using a psuedonym displays some sort of “cowardice” is all so much macho posturing, with no understanding of the damage non-anonymous blogging can do to one’s legal or academic career (or, in publius’ case, to relations with family).

Unlike publius, I’m no lawyer, so I can’t really suggest a recourse other than explaining just how abhorrent Whelan’s actions are – which he has done, in characteristically eloquent fashion. But it’s truly horrifying to see someone who fashions himself an intellectual – and who leads an at least marginally respectable think tank – sink to such depths of harassment and character assassination. Whelan is not trying to enlighten his readers; he is trying to disrupt, if not destroy, publius’ professional and personal life. As someone who, for four years, had to rely on others’ willingness to respect my anonymity in order to experience some semblance of a normal, private adolescence, few things offend me more.

But I think it behooves Whelan’s hosts – the editorial staff of National Review Online – to consider whether they want someone who personally harasses his interlocutors on their website, let alone their payroll. At the very least, I think they owe their readers an explanation if they choose to maintain their association such a bad blogospheric citizen.

2 thoughts on “Ed Whelan is Absolutely Despicable

  1. Excellent post – I was DISGUSTED when I heard of this. Ed Whelan is a pathetic joke. The only way he could ‘get even’ with his detractors is by attacking them in real life. He’s a child.

Leave a Reply to Andy Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s